Accountability, Bully Letters, bullying, FLDOE, FSA, Good Cause Exemptions, High stakes testing, intimidation, Judge Karen Gievers, K-12, Opt Out, opt out movement, PublicEdRevolution, Retention, The Opt Out Florida Network, Third grade, Third Grade FSA
by Sandy Stenoff
The Opt Out Florida Network is celebrating substantial victories today with the Order issued by Judge Karen Gievers. Mandatory Third Grade Retention is a cornerstone of Florida’s failed Accountability System that tests and punishes our students. Today was a good day for Florida’s students, but this fight is not over. Our work to support children being assessed on their 180 days of classroom work, to include the professional teacher as a primary expert in these decisions, continues.
As of today, Judge Karen Gievers ruled that Florida third graders can be promoted based on a portfolio or a report card, unless their parents have been notified that there is a reading deficiency.
Judge Gievers also confirmed that minimally participating (Opting Out) does indeed satisfy the requirement of the law.
In the coming days, Florida school districts, and the Florida Department of Education, will attempt to appeal and to ask for stays of this order. It could be heard by the Florida Supreme Court shortly.
On behalf of the families who have stood up in this lawsuit, we would like to express our gratitude for the support and generosity of all who have contributed, many repeatedly, to the legal fund. It is worth noting that many, many donations have come from educators all across the country.
While this challenge has the potential to cause statewide change, and offer support to other states looking to do the same, it will come at great expense.
For the complete ruling:
Judge Gievers’ Order 082616
From Plaintiffs’ attorney, Andrea Mogensen:
Third Grade Retention Press Release Aug26
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Andrea Mogensen
Tel: (941) 955-1066
August 26, 2016
Judge rules report cards do matter for third grade students
Education officials ordered to accept student portfolios or report cards for kids who opt out of standardized tests
Tallahassee – A Tallahassee judge delivered a decisive blow to Florida’s standardized testing scheme, telling state and local school officials that report cards and classroom participation can be used as an alternative when parents opt out of testing. In a watershed moment for students who were not promoted to the fourth grade due to their minimal participation in the Florida Standards Assessment, Judge Gievers granted a temporary injunction allowing some third graders to be promoted where school districts did not allow “a teacher-compiled portfolio that consists of non-test class work and test-based standards assessments.”
The state had argued that allowing students to opt out of standardized tests would undermine the Jeb Bush-era focus on testing, while the parents claimed that the law allowed for promotion decisions to be based on report cards and actual classroom participation.
Judge Gievers sided with the parents, finding that the Department of Education and the Hernando County School Board violated the law when they illegally refused to provide any portfolio option and that “neither the [Department of Education or local school boards] have the discretion to ignore the Florida Laws.” Gievers’ ruling defined what “minimal participation” is by stating that “the children were present at the time, broke the seal on the materials and wrote their names, thus meeting their obligation to participate.” In addition, she wrote: “The School Board and [Department of Education] had no right to ignore the legislatively adopted portfolio option” and ordered the Hernando County School Board to “immediately refrain from further actions and must provide the portfolio option.” She ordered education officials “to stop refusing to accept a student portfolio or report card based on classroom work throughout the course of the school year.”
“We are very pleased that the court agreed with us that it is in the public interest that the State Board of Education and school districts in Florida follow our laws, and focus on whether children can read, not whether they took a particular test,” said Andrea Flynn Mogensen, lead counsel for the children.
“We are especially pleased that it was specifically ordered that the Department of Education must accept minimal participation in testing as fulfilling the students’ statutory requirement to participate, and that grade 3 students with no reading deficiency should be promoted, not retained.”
The ruling came at a critical juncture for what’s known as the opt-out movement. The Department and local school boards had amassed a legal team of more than 20 lawyers to fight the lawsuit, which has been on a legal roller coaster since it was filed 16 days ago. The case was briefly removed to federal court, but the parents were able to obtain a ruling from a federal judge two days later sending it back to state court. School boards from around the state then filed an emergency appeal with the First District Court of Appeal in Tallahassee, seeking to stop Gievers from taking evidence in the case. Gievers held a marathon 9-hour hearing earlier this week, taking testimony from state educational officials from across the state as well as parents of third grade students.
A copy of the ruling can be found at http://goo.gl/aeFvOL.